1 of 36

Want to see this home?

5391 N Stahl

Monticello, IN 47960-7058

3 beds
3 baths
6 sqft
~1/2 acre lot
$129,166 per sqft
– on site

WATERFRONT PROPERTY W/2 DOCKS & 4 CAR GARAGES! This exceptional property offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort and breathtaking views of the "Big Monon Bay". Offering 65 ft of water frontage, complete with seawall, and 2 Boat docks. One of the docks is equipped with a lift. Additionally, there is a beautiful backyard patio to relax on while enjoying the views. Large country kitchen and dining combination. Two sinks and 2 disposals. Three sets of French Doors lead to the backyard. 4 season sunroom, screened in porch and primary. All leading to outside deck, patio & trees, perennial flower gardens and underground gutters. Main floor primary, Great Room w/ woodburning fireplace, bookcases made from Knotty Pine harvested from original homestead. Laundry and half bath on main. Upstairs, 2 large bedrooms, 2 full baths. Small loft and library with window seat storage. Large rec room could be converted into 2nd primary suite. Oversized 2 car garage attached and a 2-car garage detached complete with small office and kitchette with running water, insulation and heat. A perfect place to park your boats in the winter months City sewer, well water, gas heat, central air. LOMA from FEMA 5/28/24. Property is NOT located in a flood zone. A 2 hour drive from Indy & 2.5 hour drive to downtown Chicago.

Listing courtesy of IRMLS

Last checked: Checking… • Last updated Apr 7, 2025 •

MLS# 202425001 —

This home is listed in more than one place. See it here.

The Building

Year Built:

2003
New Construction:

No
Architecural Style:

Traditional
Style:

One and Half Story
Roof Material:

Asphalt
Exterior:

Other
Amenities:

Ceiling Fan(s), Deck on Waterfront, Garage Door Opener, Kitchen Island, Landscaped, Open Floor Plan, Patio Open, Porch Screened, Twin Sink Vanity, Garage-Heated, Main Floor Laundry
Basement:

No
Basement/Foundation:

None
Total SqFt:

3721
Total Finished SqFt:

3721
Main Level SqFt:

1600
Above Grade Finished SqFt:

3721
Upper Level SqFt:

2121

Interior

Kitchen Level:

Main
Dining Room Level:

Main
Living/Great Room Level:

Main
Laundry Level:

Main
Recreation Room Level:

Upper
Loft Level:

Upper
# of Fireplaces:

1
Fireplace:

Living/Great Rm
Fireplace:

Yes

Room Dimensions

Kitchen Length:

10
Kitchen Width:

15
Dining Rm Length:

18
Dining Room Width:

15
Living/Great Room Width:

15
Living/Great Room Length:

28
Recreation Room Width:

20
Loft Length:

23
Loft Width:

8
1st Bedroom Length:

17
1st Bedroom Width:

12
2nd Bedroom Length:

24
2nd Bedroom Width:

21
Recreation Room Length:

52
3rd Bedroom Width:

12
3rd Bedroom Length:

17
Laundry Room Length:

11
Laundry Room Width:

6

Location

Directions to Property:

N or SR 421 to Monticello turns into Main St Go to drive in theater go L on Ricky Rd to stop light T R Beach Rd. aka NW Shafer past Indiana Beach. Road T's go R to Parses go L 1/2 mi to Stahl Road
Inside City Limits:

No
Latitude:

40.832864
Longitude:

-86.804819

The Property

Parcel# ID:

91-83-31-000-022.600-013
Property Subtype:

Site-Built Home
Lot Number:

9
Lot Dimensions:

63x275 per county records
Lot Description:

Waterfront
Approx Lot Size SqFt:

17325
Approx Lot Size Acres:

0.397
Zoning Description:

Residential
City Zoning:

Unknown
County Zoning:

Unknown
Fence:

Decorative
Driveway:

Gravel
Waterfront:

Yes
Water Features:

Pier/Dock
Water Type:

River
Water Access:

Lakefront
Water Frontage:

65
Water Name:

Other
Road Access:

County
Road Surface:

Asphalt

Listing Agent

Contact info:

Taxes

Annual Taxes:

2664

Beds

Total # Bedrooms:

3
1st Bedroom Level:

Main
2nd Bedroom Level:

Upper
3rd Bedroom Level:

Upper

Baths

Total Baths:

4
Total Half Baths:

1
Total Full Baths:

3
# of Full Baths Main:

1
# Half Baths Main:

1
# of Full Baths Upper:

2

The Listing

Branded Virtual Tour:

https://eyesky-video-photo-film-llc.aryeo.com/videos/019070da-1c9c-73d1-ba2e-7df0c16195d4
Unbranded Virtual Tour:

https://www.propertypanorama.com/instaview/irmls/202425001

Heating & Cooling

Heating Fuel:

Forced Air
Cooling:

Central Air

Utilities

Water Utility:

Well
Well Type:

Private
Well Size:

Unknown
Sewer:

City

Schools

Elementary:

North White Primary
Middle School:

North White
High School:

North White
School District:

North White School Corp.

The Community

Subdivision:

Other
Pool:

No
Association Dues Frequency:

Not Applicable
Other Fees $:

100
Other Fee Description:

Lake Shafer permit based on number of docks
Other Fees Frequency:

Annually

Parking

Garage:

Yes
Garage Type:

Multiple
Garage Length:

22
Garage SqFt:

880
Garage Width:

40
Garage/# of Cars:

4
Off Street Parking:

Yes

Monthly cost estimate

Asking price

$775,000

Expense	Monthly cost
Mortgage	$4,149
Taxes	$1,443
Insurance	$213
Utilities	N/A
Total	$5,805/mo.^*
	^*This is an estimate

Explore the Area

My Commute

From

Walk Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Bike Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Sale history

Date	Event	Source	Price	% Change
4/2/25 Apr 2, 2025	Price Changed	IRMLS	$775,000	-12.9%
7/30/24 Jul 30, 2024	Price Changed	IRMLS	$890,000	-8.2%
7/12/24 Jul 12, 2024	Price Changed	IRMLS	$970,000	-7.6%

Want a closer look?

Go see 5391 N Stahl

Or Call Toll Free 1-800-241-3327

We guarantee that we’ll never spam you.

* indicates a required field

More homes

Newest listings in 47960

Similar sold homes

This house located in IN 47960-7058 is currently for sale for $775,000. 5391 N Stahl is a 6 square foot house with 3 beds and 3 baths that has been on Estately for 284 days. This house is in the attendance area of North White Jr.-Sr. High School, North White Primary School, and North White Intermediate School.

Listing Courtesy of: IRMLS and .

The information provided is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.