52 Tillotson Avenue
Saint James, NY 11780
- 5 beds
- 3 baths
- – sqft
- ~1/2 acre lot
- 1955 build
- – on site
Don’t miss this absolutely incredible opportunity to own a stunning custom-built Colonial with 5 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, perfectly situated mid-block in the highly sought-after Smithtown School District on a flat, private lot in a quiet neighborhood! The curb appeal is unmatched with a large expanded blacktop driveway accented by a Belgian block border, leading to a charming front porch with PVC railings and an overhang—ideal for enjoying the surroundings. Step inside to a grand entryway with gleaming hardwood floors and custom molding throughout, setting the stage for a home that exudes both elegance and comfort. The formal dining room is a showstopper, featuring crisp white walls and custom wall molding, while a French door leads to the formal living room/study, offering a private and versatile space with hardwood floors and an abundance of natural light. The chef’s kitchen is a dream, boasting radiant heated flooring, birch cabinets, a tile backsplash, granite countertops, black and stainless steel appliances, ample cabinet and counter space, plus an additional counter area with stylish double pendant lighting—all with direct access to the rear deck, making indoor-outdoor living effortless! The enormous sunken den is a standout, featuring recessed lighting, a ceiling fan, and a second gas fireplace with a wood mantel and tile insert, surrounded by oversized windows that fill the space with natural light. The first-floor powder room has been tastefully updated with a white subway tile half-wall, a sleek gray vanity with quartz countertops, and modern fixtures, while the mudroom/laundry area offers additional cabinetry and tile flooring for practicality and style. Upstairs, the primary suite is nothing short of magnificent, boasting a grand double-door entry, vaulted ceilings, recessed lighting, a full wall of windows, and a ceiling fan, leading to a spa-like ensuite with radiant heated flooring, a multi-person stand-up glass shower, a separate soaking tub, soaring ceilings, and a gorgeous vanity with maple cabinets and granite countertops. The second-floor hallway features beautiful wood floors, leading to a full hallway bath with a tub and shower, plus all generously sized additional bedrooms, each with ceiling fans. The full basement offers high ceilings, providing endless potential for additional living space, storage, or customization to suit your needs. This home is the perfect blend of classic charm and modern convenience!
Last checked:
As a licensed real estate brokerage, Estately has access to the same database professional Realtors use: the Multiple Listing Service (or MLS). That means we can display all the properties listed by other member brokerages of the local Association of Realtors—unless the seller has requested that the listing not be published or marketed online.
The MLS is widely considered to be the most authoritative, up-to-date, accurate, and complete source of real estate for-sale in the USA.
Estately updates this data as quickly as possible and shares as much information with our users as allowed by local rules. Estately can also email you updates when new homes come on the market that match your search, change price, or go under contract.
Checking…
•
Last updated Mar 24, 2025
•
MLS# 839370 —
The Building
-
Year Built:1955
-
Basement:true
-
Architectural Style:Colonial
-
Construction Materials:Frame, Vinyl Siding
-
Patio And Porch Features:Porch
-
Building Area Units:Square Feet
-
Attic:Pull Stairs
Interior
-
Total Rooms:10
-
Interior Features:Eat-in Kitchen
-
Fireplaces Total:2
-
Fireplace:true
-
Living Area Source:Other
-
# of Kitchens:1
Financial & Terms
-
Lease Considered:false
The Property
-
Fencing:Fenced
-
Lot Size Acres:0.44
-
Parcel Number:0800-053-00-03-00-002-000
-
Property Type:Residential
-
Property Subtype:Single Family Residence
-
Lot Size SqFt:19,166 Sqft
-
Property Attached:false
-
Waterfront:false
Listing Agent
- Contact info:
- Agent phone:
- (631) 759-5277
- Office phone:
- (631) 863-9800
Taxes
-
Tax Year:2024
-
Tax Source:Other
-
Tax Annual Amount:19610.22
Beds
-
Total Bedrooms:5
Baths
-
Full Baths:2
-
Half Baths:1
-
Total Baths:3
The Listing
-
Special Listing Conditions:None
Heating & Cooling
-
Heating:Baseboard
-
Cooling:Central Air
Utilities
-
Sewer:Cesspool
-
Utilities:Cable Available, Electricity Available
-
Water Source:Public
Appliances
-
Appliances:Dishwasher, Dryer, Range, Refrigerator, Washer
Schools
-
High School:Smithtown High School East
-
Elementary School:St James Elementary School
-
High School District:Smithtown
-
Middle School:Nesaquake Middle School
The Community
-
Association:false
-
Senior Community:false
Parking
-
Parking Features:Attached
-
Garage:true
-
Garage Spaces:1
-
Carport:false
Monthly cost estimate

Asking price
$849,999
Expense | Monthly cost |
---|---|
Mortgage
This calculator is intended for planning and education purposes only. It relies on assumptions and information provided by you regarding your goals, expectations and financial situation, and should not be used as your sole source of information. The output of the tool is not a loan offer or solicitation, nor is it financial or legal advice. |
$4,551
|
Taxes | $1,634 |
Insurance | $233 |
Utilities | N/A |
Total | $6,418/mo.* |
*This is an estimate |
Walk Score®
Provided by WalkScore® Inc.
Walk Score is the most well-known measure of walkability for any address. It is based on the distance to a variety of nearby services and pedestrian friendliness. Walk Scores range from 0 (Car-Dependent) to 100 (Walker’s Paradise).
Bike Score®
Provided by WalkScore® Inc.
Bike Score evaluates a location's bikeability. It is calculated by measuring bike infrastructure, hills, destinations and road connectivity, and the number of bike commuters. Bike Scores range from 0 (Somewhat Bikeable) to 100 (Biker’s Paradise).
Soundscore™
Provided by HowLoud
Soundscore is an overall score that accounts for traffic, airport activity, and local sources. A Soundscore rating is a number between 50 (very loud) and 100 (very quiet).
Sale history
Date | Event | Source | Price | % Change |
---|---|---|---|---|
3/24/25
Mar 24, 2025
|
Listed / Active | ONEKEY | $849,999 |

53% of nearby similar homes sold for over asking price
Similar homes that sold in bidding wars went $41k above asking price on average, but some went as high as $201k over asking price.