1 of 28

Want to see this home?

5 Hagar Road

Shelter Island, NY 11964

3 beds
3 baths
3,312 sqft
~1/2 acre lot
$828 per sqft
1962 build
– on site

Experience the epitome of coastal living in this meticulously maintained one-level home, nestled in a charming beach community. Renovated in 2012 by Fokine Construction, this stunning residence offers breathtaking water views of Menantic Creek from nearly every room. Inside, you'll find an open-concept floor plan featuring a vaulted living room with a cozy fireplace, a dining area, and a custom chef's kitchen. Step outside onto the waterside deck, adorned with mahogany railings and stainless wire, for a serene outdoor retreat. The primary bedroom is a true oasis, complete with two walk-in closets and a luxurious en-suite bathroom. Enjoy the tranquility of the 1.29-acre shared parcel extending into the creek. This quiet enclave offers the perfect blend of luxury and natural beauty, making it an ideal coastal retreat.

Listing courtesy of ONEKEY / Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Last checked: Checking… • Last updated Nov 16, 2024 •

MLS# 3564455 —

The Building

Year Built:

1962
Year Built Effective:

2012
New Construction:

false
Construction Materials:

Batts Insulation, Cellulose Insulation, Frame, Brick, HardiPlank Type
Architectural Style:

Ranch
Basement:

Crawl Space, Full, Unfinished, Walk-Out Access
Levels:

One
Common Walls:

No Common Walls
Door Features:

Insulated Doors
Exterior Features:

Private Entrance
Window Features:

New Windows, Double Pane Windows, Skylight(s), Insulated Windows
Patio And Porch Features:

Deck
Security Features:

Security System
Direction Faces:

Southwest
Building Area Units:

Square Feet

Interior

Interior Features:

Smart Thermostat, Master Downstairs, First Floor Bedroom, Cathedral Ceiling(s), Den/Family Room, Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Granite Counters, Living Room/Dining Room Combo, Master Bath, Powder Room, Storage, Walk-In Closet(s)
Rooms Total:

9
Flooring:

Hardwood
Fireplace:

true
Fireplaces Total:

1

Room Dimensions

Living Area:

3312
Living Area Units:

Square Feet

Location

Directions:

Take Menantic Rd. South to Hagar Rd, turn left onto Hagar and continue straight. As the road bends, continue straight onto Dickerson Drive and this home is on your left.
Cross Street:

Dickerson Dr.

The Property

Property Type:

Residential
Property Subtype:

Single Family Residence
Property Condition:

Very Good
Property Attached:

false
Zoning Description:

C-Residential
Lot Features:

Corner Lot, Sloped, Stone/Brick Wall, Private, Protected Wetlands
Lot Size Acres:

0.46
Lot Size Area:

0.46
Lot Size SqFt:

20037
Lot Size Units:

Acres
Lot Size Source:

Other
Lot Size Dimensions:

.46
Parcel Number:

0700-018-00-03-00-039-000
View:

Open, Panoramic, Water
View:

true
Waterfront Features:

Creek, Water Access, Waterfront
Flood Zone Report:

No
Road Responsibility:

Public Maintained Road

Listing Agent

Contact info:

Taxes

Tax Lot:

39
Tax Block:

3
Tax Map Number:

0700-018-00-03-00-039-000
Tax Annual Amount:

6288.84

Beds

Bedrooms Total:

3

Baths

Total Baths:

3
Half Baths:

1
Full Baths:

2

Heating & Cooling

Heating:

Oil, Baseboard, Hot Water, ENERGY STAR Qualified Equipment
Cooling:

ENERGY STAR Qualified Equipment

Utilities

Sewer:

Cesspool, Septic Tank
Water Source:

Well

Appliances

Appliances:

Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Washer, Water Purifier Owned, ENERGY STAR Qualified Dishwasher, ENERGY STAR Qualified Dryer, ENERGY STAR Qualified Refrigerator, ENERGY STAR Qualified Washer

Schools

Elementary School:

Shelter Island School
Elementary School District:

Shelter Island
Middle Or Junior School:

Shelter Island School
Middle Or Junior School District:

Shelter Island
High School:

Shelter Island School
High School District:

Shelter Island

The Community

Community Features:

Park
Senior Community:

false

Parking

Garage:

true
Garage Spaces:

2
Attached Garage:

true
Parking Features:

Private, Attached, 2 Car Attached, Driveway

Monthly cost estimate

Asking price

$2,745,000

Expense	Monthly cost
Mortgage	$14,698
Taxes	$524
Insurance	$754
Utilities	$548 See report
Total	$16,524/mo.^*
	^*This is an estimate

Explore the Area

My Commute

From

Walk Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Bike Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Air Pollution Index

Provided by ClearlyEnergy

Sale history

Date	Event	Source	Price	% Change
10/5/24 Oct 5, 2024	Price Changed	ONEKEY	$2,745,000	-5.2%
8/27/24 Aug 27, 2024	Price Changed	ONEKEY	$2,895,000	-6.6%
7/9/24 Jul 9, 2024	Listed / Active	ONEKEY	$3,100,000

Want a closer look?

Go see 5 Hagar Road

Or Call Toll Free 1-800-241-3327

We guarantee that we’ll never spam you.

* indicates a required field

More homes

Newest listings in Shelter Island, NY

Similar sold homes

This house located in Shelter Island, NY 11964 is currently for sale for $2,745,000. 5 Hagar Road is a 3,312 square foot house with 3 beds and 3 baths that has been on Estately for 131 days.

Listing Courtesy of: ONEKEY and Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal non-commercial use. It may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.