1 of 31

Want to see this home?

5 Bay Avenue

Shelter Island, NY 11964

3 beds
3 baths
1,675 sqft
$10 per sqft
1951 build
– on site

Open plan beach house with superb water views located in the highly sought after Montclair Colony. Centrally located near markets and many conveniences, there is much to adore in this home. Open plan living room with sunroom, dining and eat in kitchen. This home offers two bedrooms with two full baths and another bedroom with a full bath over the two car garage. In addition the master bedroom has a walk-in closet. Come see the private large deck, enclosed sunporch and gunite pool. Convenient to town beaches and other popular destinations. There is water access at the end of the street. MD-LD $70K June $18K July $25K August $30K Yr - $7K per month ($84K annual)

Listing courtesy of ONEKEY / Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Last checked: Checking… • Last updated Mar 9, 2025 •

MLS# 823843 —

The Building

Year Built:

1951
Basement:

true
Architectural Style:

Ranch
Construction Materials:

Advanced Framing Technique
Building Area Units:

Square Feet
Attic:

Crawl
Smoking:

No

Interior

Living Area:

1675
Total Rooms:

9
Interior Features:

First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Built-in Features, High Speed Internet, Primary Bathroom, Open Floorplan, Open Kitchen, Walk-In Closet(s)
Living Area Source:

Plans

Financial & Terms

Availability Date:

2025-02-13

The Property

Lot Size Acres:

0.58
Parcel Number:

0700-022-00-02-00-042-000
Property Type:

Residential Lease
Property Subtype:

Single Family Residence
Lot Size SqFt:

25,265 Sqft
Property Attached:

false
Waterfront:

false

Listing Agent

Contact info:

Beds

Total Bedrooms:

3

Baths

Full Baths:

3
Total Baths:

3

The Listing

Special Listing Conditions:

Security Deposit

Heating & Cooling

Heating:

Baseboard
Cooling:

Central Air
# of Heating Zones:

2

Utilities

Sewer:

Septic Tank
Utilities:

Electricity Connected
Water Source:

Drilled Well

Appliances

Appliances:

Convection Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Electric Water Heater, ENERGY STAR Qualified Appliances, Freezer, Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer

Schools

High School:

Shelter Island School
Elementary School:

Contact Agent
High School District:

Shelter Island
Middle School:

Shelter Island School

The Community

Association:

false
Seasonal:

Yes
Senior Community:

false
Pool Private:

true
Pets Allowed:

Call

Parking

Garage:

true
Garage Spaces:

2
Carport:

false

Explore the Area

My Commute

From

Walk Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Bike Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Air Pollution Index

Provided by ClearlyEnergy

Utility Costs

$388/mo.

Estimate provided by ClearlyEnergy

View a full report

House For Rent

$18,000/mo

Listing provided by broker:

Michael Brennan

Douglas Elliman Real Estate

631-725-0200

Want a closer look?

Go see 5 Bay Avenue

Or Call Toll Free 1-800-241-3327

We guarantee that we’ll never spam you.

* indicates a required field

More homes for rent

Newest for rent listings in Shelter Island, NY

This house located in Shelter Island, NY 11964 is currently for rent for $18,000/mo. 5 Bay Avenue is a 1,675 square foot house with 3 beds and 3 baths that has been on Estately for 36 days.

Listing Courtesy of: ONEKEY and Douglas Elliman Real Estate.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal non-commercial use. It may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.