1 of 39

Want to see this home?

15a / 15 & 13 S Menantic Road

Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964

9 beds
6 baths
3,944 sqft
~3 acre lot
$2,524 per sqft
1983 build
– on site

For the first time in over a century, this extraordinary collection of generationally owned properties is being offered together as a singular and rare opportunity. Nestled along the serene and picturesque Menantic Creek, these three distinct parcels span a combined 4.9 acres, presenting an unrivaled waterfront retreat. At the heart of this offering is 15A Menantic Road, a legally designated two-family residence with a breathtaking 3,944 square feet of meticulously renovated living space. This refined home features five bedrooms, 4 full, two 1/2 baths, and a 483-square-foot garage, all thoughtfully designed to maximize the stunning creek views. Taxes: $12,206.00 Adjacent to this residence is 15 Menantic Road, a pristine and vacant 1.3-acre parcel, offering endless potential to further enhance this exceptional estate. Taxes: $4,325.00 Completing the trio is 13 Menantic Road, a charming 1930s bungalow with two bedrooms and one bath set on 1.47 acres and a brand new two story 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home with attached two car garage in the final stages of completion. Taxes: $8,521.00 What truly sets this estate apart is its extraordinary arboretum-like setting, adorned with a curated collection of rare and mature specimen trees, including Copper Beech, Southern Magnolia, White Birch, Monkey Puzzle, Dawn Redwoods, Linden, Osage Orange, Red Japanese Maple, and Dogwood. The natural beauty of this land is simply unparalleled. For the boating enthusiast, this offering includes a 100-foot stationary dock, complete with a 6-foot-wide walkway with a bench, as well as a 12-foot plastic ramp leading to a 30x6 floating dock with three anchor pilings. Two moorings on the creek are also available, pending reapplication. This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own a waterfront compound with limitless potential—a legal multi-family residence, a historic bungalow, a new construction home and an untouched parcel—all in one of the most coveted locations. A truly rare find for the discerning buyer seeking exclusivity, natural beauty, and unparalleled waterfront living.

Listing courtesy of ONEKEY / Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Last checked: Checking… • Last updated Apr 8, 2025 •

MLS# 842673 —

The Building

Year Built:

1983
Basement:

true
Architectural Style:

Contemporary
Construction Materials:

Frame
Patio And Porch Features:

Deck, Patio
Building Area Units:

Square Feet
Building Area Total:

3944
Exterior Features:

Basketball Court, Basketball Hoop, Boat Slip, Dock, Dog Run, Garden, Mooring, Playground, Rain Gutters
Laundry Features:

Electric Dryer Hookup
Attic:

Full
Direction Faces:

East

Interior

Levels:

Two
Living Area:

3944
Total Rooms:

16
Interior Features:

First Floor Full Bath, Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Formal Dining, Primary Bathroom
Fireplace Features:

Family Room, Living Room, Wood Burning Stove
Fireplaces Total:

2
Fireplace:

true
Flooring:

Ceramic Tile, Hardwood, Vinyl
Living Area Source:

Other
Additional Rooms:

Dining Area,Home Office,Library/Den

Financial & Terms

Lease Considered:

false

The Property

Fencing:

Back Yard, Front Yard
Lot Features:

Back Yard, Cleared, Front Yard, Garden, Level
Lot Size Acres:

2.9
Parcel Number:

0700-018-00-03-00-012-002
Property Type:

Residential
Property Subtype:

Single Family Residence
Property Attached:

true
Additional Parcels:

true
Waterfront:

true
Road Frontage Type:

County Road
Road Responsibility:

Public Maintained Road
Horse:

false

Listing Agent

Contact info:

Taxes

Tax Year:

2024
Tax Source:

Other
Tax Annual Amount:

25052

Beds

Total Bedrooms:

9

Baths

Full Baths:

4
Half Baths:

2
Total Baths:

6

The Listing

Special Listing Conditions:

None
Virtual Tour URL Unbranded:

Virtual Tour

Heating & Cooling

Heating:

Electric
Cooling:

Central Air

Utilities

Sewer:

Cesspool
Utilities:

Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Trash Collection Private, Water Connected
Water Source:

Well
Electric Company:

Pseg

Appliances

Appliances:

Convection Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Electric Cooktop, Electric Oven, Electric Water Heater, Exhaust Fan, Freezer, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer

Schools

High School:

Shelter Island School
Elementary School:

Contact Agent
High School District:

Shelter Island
Middle School:

Shelter Island School

The Community

Association:

false
Senior Community:

false
Pool Private:

false
Spa:

false

Parking

Parking Features:

Driveway, Garage, Shared Driveway
Garage:

true
Garage Spaces:

2
Carport:

false

Extra Units

Other Structures:

Garage(s), Guest House, Outbuilding, Shed(s)

Monthly cost estimate

Asking price

$9,955,000

Expense	Monthly cost
Mortgage	$53,305
Taxes	$2,087
Insurance	$2,737
Utilities	$528 See report
Total	$58,657/mo.^*
	^*This is an estimate

Explore the Area

My Commute

From

Walk Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Bike Score®

Provided by WalkScore® Inc.

Air Pollution Index

Provided by ClearlyEnergy

Sale history

Date	Event	Source	Price	% Change
3/31/25 Mar 31, 2025	Listed / Active	ONEKEY	$9,955,000

Want a closer look?

Go see 15a / 15 & 13 S Menantic Road

Or Call Toll Free 1-800-241-3327

We guarantee that we’ll never spam you.

* indicates a required field

More homes

Newest listings in Shelter Island, NY

Similar sold homes

This house located in Shelter Island, NY 11964 is currently for sale for $9,955,000. 15a / 15 & 13 S Menantic Road is a 3,944 square foot house with 9 beds and 6 baths that has been on Estately for 14 days.

Listing Courtesy of: ONEKEY and Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal non-commercial use. It may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.